Eatalia in Huntington

Nice place good service.priced good .

Love it. Best Italian in Huntington.

The best NYC Italian experience

The food was great the service was fantastic.

Awesome food

Best Italian in Huntington circa 2019

Mediocre food at best...also would not accept Groupon for lunch which Groupon does not say in fine print. Food tasted reheated or frozen. Very disappointed. A year ago it was decent but has gone down hill . Many better options out there

Food is excellent! By far the best in the area and they DELIVER (which makes life a lot easier)! Happened to find this place by accident when I needed quarters for the parking meter outside... I'm glad I did though because I'm a very picky Italian American and I have tried every place in the Huntington, Greenlawn, Melville area. Don't get me wrong, I found some good places (and some horrible ones) but even the good places that I've found have issues with being consistent. This place has great food and is consistent. From their pizza to their dinners everything has been better than anywhere else that I've tried over the past year and a half. I will note that i strongly suggest ordering the family style to get more bang for your buck.

Terrific veal parm among best have ever had. Friendly pleasant efficient service and every dish we have tried has been delicious and enjoyable. Is has become one of our go to places.

Great food and service Stumbled across here the other weekend Will go back

Great food and good environment. Very friendly staff...Overall great experience

Great food, nice service.

I enjoyed our meal here. The staff were nice, the food was delicious, I'm not sure I could ask for anything more.

The resturant is immaculate. The food was excellent, and staff were very accommodating.

The hard working group here produces very fine food at decent prices. The establishment knows what they are doing in the kitchen. Every meal I have had here has been really, really on point.

Very nice place. Food was also very good with nice sized portions. Friendly and professional staff. Recommended.

Good food great service

Good food good price

Food and service was great, especially putting up with the 4 noisy kids we had with us. Would definitely go there again..

Delish and reasonable. Pleasant waitress.

Food is delicious!!!!

Great food we will be back

Great spot for family groups or lunch. Great lunch menu with lots of options for $10.99. Family style options is great for large groups and good sized portions. Food is very good and staff is friendly.

Good good, good service, good value

Excellent food and service! Al and staff do a great job!

3rd visit to this gem of a restaurant. Arrived with a group of 5 and ordered everything family style. Started with a delicious roasted red pepper salad with mixed greens, gorgonzola, Granny Smith apples wedges with a delicate red pepper dressing. We also ordered braised short ribs with mashed potato... Super tender ribs and a scrumptious brown gravy and homemade mashed potatoes. We enjoyed the most amazing pasta dish... "Salese"...We substituted a gluten free penne (its normally served with papardelle).. what a dish! Mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes, fresh peas in a creamy heavenly sauce with a touch of truffle oil. Broccoli rabe with garlic, sausage and canellini beans was excellent. The service is super friendly and attentive and the food can't be beat! Tutto buono!!!

Highly recommend this family style restaurant. Extensive menu , friendly staff and reasonably priced.

Always a good meal with excellent service!

Fantastic food loved it

From the moment you step in that place the stuff gives you an enjoyable feeling. Very friendly waiters, it is a good restaurant to hang out with your friends or with your date. heavenly meals, specialist chief cook and stuff, competitive pay and generous service. Highly recommended.

Not great, not awful. Pretty average food.

My family had dinner there on New Years Eve and it was FABULOUS!!! Cozy atmospher, GREAT service, with entrées served family style and they are gluten free friendly!! The spinach salad was yummy and each entree was delicious! And, don't forget dessert!

The food is good but make sure you make it very LOUD & CLEAR what LEFTOVERS you would like wrapped , as the waiter threw away a shrimp risotto dish but wrapped the pastas dishes

Great experience.Al and his staff do a great job. Soups are on point and pastas outstanding. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Food was good, service was friendly.

First time there. Food was really good. Service too

Quiet, great food, good service. No rushExcellent

Nice ambience, good service and well maintained dining area, the ravioli is good, the sauce could use a little kick.

Love their lunches. Great service, and very friendly people.

Not sure what happened in 5 months but the food and service was completely different from the last time. The fried calamari was rubbery. The Baratta special was dried out?the veal cutlets tasted like breading with sauce, asked for angel hair pasta and got rigatoni? It was not just one person but all of us felt the same way. We needed to ask for plates, silverware when we ordered desserts. Had to ask for cream twice and was brought milk for our coffee's. Will not go back.

Food is great, restaurant is neat and clean... Try the short rib 🤩

My family and friends love Eatalia! Great food, great service!

We located the restaurant on New Street, across from the municipal parking. The service and food were excellent. The menu is available to order either individually or family style. The food is prepared fresh and our waiter informed us we could alter the meals to suit our taste. Not fancy from the outside, but nice on the inside. We will return to sample other creations.

Addicted to the penne alla vodka. Great staff and the perfect place for a large party!

The food was really great as well as the decor and specially the service. the only reason why this is not a 5-star review is because this restaurant was stuck on Billy Joel mode all night. I certainly I'm a fan of Billy Joel but there's plenty of other music that came out in the last 40 years that an Italian restaurant can play.

As I looked at the menu this restaurant doesn’t have many choices at all. One of the dishes we got were odd. As my chicken was cut in half in 3 small cutlets which looked like chicken nuggets, this does not suit my value as well as was served without pasta or salad. If you want a salad or pasta it’s an expensive upcharge. Seriously not one Italian restaurant On Long Island compare to the ParkSide restaurant in Corona Queens. Which by far is a 20 minute drive and well worth ever single penny. For what I spent I could have go 2 meals an a appetizer of any kind at Parkside. So I will never recommend this place to anyone or ever go again.

Went for a function, great family style food, hospitable staff, great time!

Not sure how long these guys have been here, but in the short amount of time that they have been open they have established themselves as the best pizza place in Huntington, and it isn't even close.

Generous and delicious family style portions of Tagliatelle Bolognese, Chicken Scarpiello and Veal Cutlet Parmigiana with an Eatalia Pizzette and Beet Salad to start. Service was excellent. Looking forward to next visit.

Great place off the beaten path